This is an extraordinarily subtle performance of Schubert's first great cycle. Wonderfully recorded, with an ideal balance between soloist and pianist, it leaves you wondering, at times, who is accompanying whom...Maltman, with his gloriously warm light baritone, is born along on the stream of the piano's uncertainties, and the total effect is disturbing and unique...indispensable for anyone wanting to probe beneath its adorable surface.

Maltman brings a fierce intelligence and a wide range of vocal colour to his performance, and he manages to balance a sense of overarching emotional control from beginning to end with in-the-moment spontaneity...Graham Johnson's accompanying - which now supports, now ironizes the ostensible emotion of the song - adds depth too.

Maltman's journeyman miller is volatile, susceptible, prone to violent swings between elation and self-communing inwardness, but not one who senses his tragic fate virtually from the outset. With its fine bright resonance, his virile baritone initially exudes health and an eagerness to seize life...Maltman's ardent, impulsive, intensely 'lived' performance, partnered and inspired by the ever-illuminating Johnson, should be heard by anyone who loves the cycle.

After only moments in the opening song, 'Das Wandern', one becomes aware that Maltman's singing will not be vocally monochromic...This is a extremely introspective reading, controlled, collected and sensitive...Johnson brings his own eloquent contributions.

This performance...is uncommonly convincing in its combination of vividness and deep introspection...A strong point is Johnson’s piano-playing...but this is very much a partnership. Maltman is a compelling narrator, making you see the pictures and moods described, and imaginatively mixing half-voice and vehement full tone. The Hateful Colour is thrillingly dramatic.