…the momentum of Keilberth's conducting offers strong support to the dark Wotan of Hans Hotter, and to the scheming of both Gustav Neidlinger's Alberich and Rudolf Lustig's Loge. This Donner (Toni Blankenheim) is a hammer-swinging Thor, and the Froh of the Austrian tenor Josef Traxl has a lyrical sense of innocence.

Here we are at the start of the revelatory Bayreuth Ring of 1955, and from the very first primordial sounds Joseph Keilberth establishes that this is to be a very special cycle. The opening scene is dominated by Gustav Neidlinger's nonpareil of an Alberich, who in the third scene becomes a frightening incarnation of malevolent power. But the Rhinemaidens aren't as steady as one might wish.
Scene 2 brings a kaleidoscope of authoritative interpretations, headed by Hans Hotter's commanding Wotan, a thoughtful portrait of an overweening, troubled figure sung with a Lieder- like attention to verbal detail. Georgine von Milinkovi? is a suitably imposing Fricka and a convincing nag. Ludwig Weber's expressive, articulate Fasolt is partnered by Josef Greindl's louring Fafner. Rudolf Lustig's strongly sung Loge – no comprimario tenor he – is not the most fluent piece of singing, but he gives the text real meaning. Among the minor gods Josef Traxel stands out for his beautifully lyric Froh, luxury casting from one of the leading tenors then active in Germany. Maria von Ilosvay as Erda and Paul Kuen as Mime are just as characterful as in in Siegfried. Over all you have once again a sense of a truly experienced ensemble, each member of which plays to the other.
Once again, one is astounded by the ideal capturing of the Bayreuth acoustics and by the superlative playing of the orchestra, stimulated by Keilberth's astutely dramatic conducting.

Keilberth's conducting throughout is electrifyingly intense...[Hotter] is here at his very finest early in his career, his voice steady as rock. Gustav Niedlinger as Alberich also gives a classic performance...The rest of the cast cannot be faulted, making this a hot contender in a closely competitive field, matching and even outshining most more recent versions.